February 15, 2022
Center for Education Opportunity
Toolkit: Protecting Your Taxpayer Dollars in the Classroom
February 15, 2022
The COVID-19 pandemic and heightened tensions over the teaching of racial and social issues have made curriculum, school boards, and education transparency a top priority among grassroots, parents, students, and politicians alike. Grassroots (citizen activists in a community) must have the tools they need to advocate for transparent and quality spending of their tax payer dollars.
As our students go back to school, it is more important than ever that grassroots activists have the resources they need to actively engage in students’ education and make sure schools are held accountable. Roughly 56 million students are attending elementary and secondary schools in America, and taxpayers have the right to transparency and accountability in their school district.
In a recent poll from Parents Defending Education, 80 percent of people opposed the use of classrooms to promote political activism. When asked, the overwhelming majority of Americans did not want students taught political propaganda that America is structurally racist, indoctrinated with anti-scientific ideas that there is no such thing as biological sex, taught that white students are inherently privileged and oppressors toward other minority groups, and/or taught historical distortions about America’s founding being rooted in racism.
Despite the opposition to these dubious teachings, the political rise of “wokeness” and ideas such as Critical Race Theory (CRT), The 1619 Project, and action civics have brought these race-centric concepts and policies into thousands of schools across the country (Burke et al., n.d.-a). Examples across the country include:
- An elementary school in Philadelphia forced fifth-grade students to simulate a black power rally, and the 10 and 11-year-old students marched on a stage with signs that said “Jail Trump” and “Black Power.” The entirety of the Philadelphia Public School System has adopted a new “Antiracism Declaration,” and the local teachers union put out a video denouncing the United States as a “colony built on White supremacy and capitalism.”
- Evanston/Skokie School District 65 in Illinois is teaching K-8 students that “Racism is a white person’s problem and we are all caught up in it,” that “White people have a very, very serious problem and they should start thinking about what they should do about it,” and that white students should “sit in [their] discomfort” (Southeastern Legal Foundation, 2021).
- North Carolina’s largest school district launched a campaign against “whiteness in educational spaces” and instructed teachers to ignore parents’ concerns about their equity programs (Rufo, 2021c).
- In Cupertino, California, an elementary school required third graders to analyze their racial identities and rank themselves according to their “power and privilege” (Rufo, 2021a).
- The lesson plans of public schools in Buffalo, New York, suggest that when students are in kindergarten, teachers ask students to compare their skin color and watch a video that illustrates dead black kids speaking to them about the dangers of being killed by “racist police and state-sanctioned violence” (Rufo,2021b).
- Oregon Department of Education has adopted CRT in mathematics, going as far as to say that White supremacy is reinforced by the belief that teachers are teachers and students are students and that valuing independent work is White Supremacy culture.
- California education officials are urging teachers to adopt “A Pathway to Equitable Math Instruction: Dismantling Racism in Mathematics Instruction.” The guide is geared explicitly toward math but provides a “collective approach to dismantling white supremacy.”
- Rockville Center High School in New York gave out a homework assignment that “demonized” the police.
- This is proof that grassroots have the right to be concerned that these teachings could come to their schools. The United States has worked hard to develop into a country driven by character, work ethic, and virtue, not a race and biological identity. The growing movement of race-centric, anti-American thought and rhetoric in our schools threatens to dismantle that very achievement. These policies are a step back into a time when it was acceptable to treat people differently based on the color of their skin.
Public schools and state and local district school boards are accountable to the taxpayer. With the appropriate tools, grassroots can become involved and ensure that students are receiving the best possible education. There has never been a more critical time to advocate for our students and the preservation of America.
This toolkit provides 8 ways for grassroots to ensure that students have access to quality education.
1. ENGAGING WITH LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS
What are Local School Boards?
- School board members wield a great deal of power as elected officials. Local school district boards do not report to the state board of education. They only are accountable to the voters in their local jurisdiction—that means YOU!
- Local school boards establish and maintain a basic organizational structure for the local school system.
- There are roughly 14,000 school boards across the country and about 100,000 school board members and 95 percent of the school board members are elected to their positions. They represent the largest group of elected officials in the country
- School board members set a district’s priorities for spending, resolve legal and disciplinary issues, acquire land, and even initiate eminent domain proceedings. They ensure that curricula meet federal and state mandates for public schools, appoint superintendents, adopt budgets, and help to maintain educational excellence.
What Happens at a School Board Meeting?
- Every board meeting is different, but listed below are the common components occurring in most meetings. Please review your school board’s policies to ensure the exact procedures of your school board meeting.
- A local school board’s parliamentary procedure is a matter of local policy. Most boards follow Roberts Rules of Order, which describes how meetings are run, how motions and votes are taken, and other procedures. Usually, the superintendent or school board president gives a general update and announcements before any new business.
- The most effective way to get an item that requires board action onto the agenda is to contact the board president or superintendent before the meeting. Items can be added to the agenda at the beginning of a meeting, but it is more difficult because there would need to be a motion made by a board member to amend the agenda to add an item and must be affirmed by a vote of the board members. To help board members be prepared for meetings, it is better to have a new agenda item added before the actual meeting.
- Board members follow a pre-approved agenda. There are two opportunities for public input at board meetings:
- During the time for public comment on agenda items at the beginning of the meeting.
- During the time for public comment at the end of the meeting.
- Board members listen to public input and take it into account during discussion and deliberation. However, Board members have no direct interaction with the public during a regular school board meeting.
- The board president acknowledges and thanks members of the public for their input as appropriate. Once Board members make their comments, they will move to discussion on an agenda item. At this point, the audience (you) and staff no longer participate.
On the following page is a screenshot of a board meeting agenda from Virginia Beach City Public Schools.
Thoroughly reading an agenda and supplemental materials is a great way to help identify policies that don’t align with your values and can give you an avenue to advocate for the policies you would like to see.
Good school board meeting agendas are detailed and include links to documents being discussed and note when updates are made to the agenda. By clicking on the photo at the top of the following page, you can see the entire detailed agenda. This includes discussions on religious exemptions, non-discrimination policies, the treatment of transgender students, employment actions, student suspension policies, and much more. This is an example of an informative school board agenda meeting materials.
How Can Grassroots Get Involved?
- Grassroots should search when and where the school board meetings take place. Usually, they take place at least once a month. Information on school board meetings is on the school district website.
- School board meetings are public meetings and are required to give public notice at least 5 days before the meeting date and time. Attending local school board meetings helps grassroots stay vigilant and keeps them aware of what is being taught in the community.
- Grassroots can keep track of board activities by reading the meeting minutes (notes of what happened), which must be posted on the school district website.
- Board meeting minutes will also include budget documents to observe spending on all activities, trainings, and any personnel changes.
- Reviewing the school board’s mission and vision statements posted on their websites will help you become familiar with their priorities as a board and their policies and procedures.
- Many school boards have committees and workgroups that give the school board advice or make recommendations about issues. For example, school boards are typically required by law to involve parents, teachers, students, and community members in developing and reviewing school policies. School board directors are often eager to hear from grassroots who volunteer their time. Contact your school board members and offer to help with any workgroup.
- Grassroots can set up an activist group on social media for community members to share information and activities for more involvement opportunities.
- Grassroots can contact school board members directly. Usually, contact information for individual board members can be found on the school district’s website under “board members.” If it is not posted online, contact the number on the website and request this information.
- Grassroots have the right to ask school board members their position on various issues.
Sample Questions about Curriculum Adoption:
- Has this district adopted a curriculum focused on “antiracism,” “dismantling White Supremacy or privilege,” “equity,” “social or racial justice,” or any content that suggests biological factors play a major role in societal opportunity?
- If so, these are elements of CRT. How do you believe these to be elements of a high-quality curriculum? How do you believe these teach students to prioritize hard work, merit, and equal treatment of peers independent of biology?
- Where can we find the approved academic standards for each grade level?
- What is included in the school district’s diversity and inclusion plan?
- How much money and time are you spending on race, gender, equity, diversity, and social justice programs?
- What accountability measures do you have in place to ensure the supplemental materials used in classrooms are aligned with a high-quality curriculum?
- What do you define as a high-quality curriculum?
2. MEETING WITH LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS
Meeting with individual school board members is a great way to fully understand their views on issues and obtain more information on given topics. School board member information is typically posted on the website (if you cannot find their email or phone number, you can call the district line), and many members will take time to meet with you or a small group of parents.
Strategies for Speaking with School Board Members:
- When setting up the meeting, be specific about what you are interested in discussing. Be clear if you are planning to discuss general topics or a particular policy.
- Consider bringing other grassroots with you for the meeting with a board member. Keep the meeting small and let the board member know who you will be bringing ahead of time.
- Grassroots and community members have a lot of expertise to bring to school board members. Be sure to connect with them by sharing a personal story of how the policy you are discussing is affecting students and families. Be sure to share your expertise on the issue as well as suggested solutions to the issue. Your expertise does not need to be your professional or educational background. As a taxpayer, your expertise may be rooted in your experience as a mother or father or even a concerned community member.
- Follow up with the entire school board after your member meeting. It is always helpful to present your concerns or points officially to the entire school board through a letter or one-page summary on the topic. These notes will then become part of the public record and are included in the board minutes. You can do this by sending an email to all members of the school board or the board secretary.
- School board members typically have official email addresses with the school district. Letters, emails, and phone calls can also be a good way to communicate with them. A sample letter is linked below:
Sample Letter to the School Board
**Below is a screenshot of the opening of the letter
3. REQUESTING ACCESS TO CURRICULUM PLANS AND INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
As a parent, you have the right to request access to the curriculum and instructional materials. Parents often receive materials directly from the school through your child’s packet of information sent home throughout the year. As a parent, you also have the right to speak with your child’s teacher and principal. In addition, parents can request to see the materials used in their child’s classroom.
The school district website also provides additional details about meetings, trainings, and programs on diversity, equity, and inclusion. Through state freedom of information or sunshine laws, parents can request to see public records more formally. All trainings, programs, and curricula related to CRT or equity-based curricula can be requested. Once you receive the documents, you can share what you observed with parents and post them on social media.
By clicking the link above, choose the state the child attends school in and select “Sample Freedom Of Information Act request.” It will give you an outline, like below, that can formally request information from the school district.
How to Submit an Open Records Request:
Each state has its laws for record requests and open meeting requirements. Open Records laws detail the records, documents, and information of state agencies and local governments. Most freedom of information laws require that public records requests be made in writing. The National Freedom of Information Coalition is a great resource that provides information about individual state laws along with sample letters of request by state. All state agencies in government must disclose if requested. Your state may offer trainings and guides to educate citizens about the specific laws in their state, best practices for making requests, and resources for citizens when agencies fail to comply with requests. A list of additional resources about your state laws can be found here.
- Identify the appropriate person to send the letter to.
- Be specific about what you are requesting but not overly narrow about the labels or terms you use. For example, schools may respond that they do not teach “critical race theory” if that exact phrase does not to appear in any course materials. However, if, in addition to “critical race theory,” you also list critical race theory scholars or topics like “curriculum materials that discuss systemic racism and disadvantages to meritocracy,” you are more likely to receive the information you are looking for. As another example, you can say, “materials used in teacher training from 2020-21 school year, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion materials for 2020-21 school year, outgoing and incoming emails from Mrs. Jones from January 1, 2020 – July 31, 2021.”
- Confirm receipt.
- Pay any fees.
- Follow-up with regular emails until it is received. Many Districts have legally mandated timelines to return your requests, and if they want more time, they need to state a reason. Be prepared to respond to any such requests. You can object or agree.
4. VOTING IN SCHOOL BOARD ELECTIONS
There are roughly 14,000 school boards across the country and about 100,000 school board members. Of these school board members, 95 percent are elected to their positions. They represent the largest group of elected officials in the country.
School board elections receive the least amount of attention and have the lowest voter turnout. From 2018 to 2020, Ballotpedia covered elections for 2,803 school board seats in 960 school districts across the United States. They found that between 35 percent and 40 percent of the school board elections covered were unopposed each year and that incumbents won between 57 percent and 61 percent of contested seats.
The quality of public schools is largely dependent on school board decisions regarding how children are educated and how your tax dollars are spent. Local school board elections are an opportunity for grassroots to express views on education issues by voting for a candidate that best aligns with those views. It is a powerful way to support children. With low voter turnout for such an important position, there are many ways that grassroots can encourage people to vote in these crucial elections.
What to Look for in a School Board Candidate:
- Does the school board candidate have a genuine interest in improving public schools?
- Do they have a background that supports helping children? Are they positively involved in the community?
- Is the candidate a visionary and able to understand the system and help plan for the future?
- Does the candidate know about public schools? Are they aware of the issues in your district?
- Are they committed to public education? Do they believe in the importance of public education and that every child deserves an outstanding education?
- Do not be afraid to ask what they believe is “high quality” education and for curriculum plans they have seen and think would benefit the school.
- Is the candidate committed to a high-quality curriculum?
- Does the candidate share the same values as you, and are they committed to preserving those values in local schools?
- Make sure to look for whether the candidate is being funded by a group or individual that supports divisive concepts.
- Are they focused on putting students front and center and not special interests?
5. RUNNING AS A CANDIDATE FOR YOUR LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD
You do not need a background in public education or public policy to run for a school board position. Although it differs from state to state, there are some common qualifications that most states have to be eligible to be a candidate for a school board election. Check with your local school board to see your specific requirements. The most common candidate requirements:
- Be a registered voter.
- Be a resident of the district that he or she is running in.
- Have at least a high school diploma or a certificate of high school equivalency.
- Have no felonies.
- Not be a current employee of the district and/or be related to a current employee in that district.
Some states require candidates to file a petition to run for a school board position. These petitions require a certain number of valid signatures and sometimes a small filing fee. Check with your county election commission or district superintendent’s office to determine your exact local requirements.
Becoming a school board member is a significant commitment. It takes time and dedication to be an influential member. Candidates may run for a school board seat because they have a child in the district and want to impact education or because they want to serve and support the district.
To find out information about your next local school board election, you can visit the district website. If you cannot find this information on the website, you can call the district or the superintendent’s office for more details.
Running for School Board Position:
To bring awareness of your interest in serving on the school board, a good start is to share information with the community. Candidates can reach out and connect with thousands of voters through social media platforms for little to no cost. Here are some suggestions on how to begin a campaign after you have filed your paperwork for candidacy.
- Create a Facebook page, Instagram account, and Twitter account to promote your campaign. These accounts are usually free and can be easily accessed and shared by friends, family, and supporters. These accounts should be updated frequently and be used to reach your constituents daily. For extra amplification, you could use the promotional features offered by the platforms to reach more viewers. Make sure you are only advertising to people in your district and eligible to vote for you.
- Utilize your church community for support and awareness. Your church community is a great ally. Many families are eager to volunteer and rally behind your cause.
- Knock on doors in your community and introduce yourself to your neighbors. Your volunteers from church or social clubs could also help knock on doors on your behalf. Face-to-face interactions are important to help your community get to know you better and remind them of the upcoming election. Make sure to have a pamphlet or palm card to leave with potential voters.
- Make use of yard signs to increase name recognition and serve as a reminder of upcoming elections. These signs should feature your name and what position you are running for in big, bold, and easy-to-read font.
- Host meet the candidate events in local public venues. It can be as simple as hosting an event in a neighborhood park, inviting friends and neighbors, and asking them to invite a few friends themselves. If permissible, you can also organize an ice cream truck to meet you in a local neighborhood for a casual ice cream social or host an event in your local public library. These events should be simple, cost-effective, and give the community a chance to speak with you one-on-one.
- Recruit volunteers to help you make phone calls, knock on doors, organize events, and educate the public on your campaign. Volunteers should be local community members, including members of the youth community. Colleges and universities often have clubs and organizations of students that love to get involved.
- Build a campaign website to present information about yourself and the issues that are important to you. Keep the website updated with news and events to make it easy for voters to view your position on current events on education. You can also include a campaign press kit for voters and local media. The kit can include a candidate biography, cover letter describing yourself and the campaign, digital copies of brochures and flyers, headshots or photographs, and a frequently asked questions document on the major issues facing the candidate.
- Local media, including newspapers, radio, and TV, are a great way to gain name recognition while advocating for issues that are important to you. Send short and simple press releases announcing your candidacy and what your vision is for the district. Keep them under half a page, and make sure to include your district, name, campaign contact information, and webpage.
- Do not be afraid to fundraise. Fundraising is often an intimidating part of campaigning but don’t let it scare you! Fundraising can be done through in-person asks or on your digital platforms. Before making any asks, make sure you familiarize yourself with campaign finance laws (these are state-specific and can be found on your Secretary of State webpage). And remember, by donating to you, people are investing in the future of their child’s education. A thank you note is customary when someone gives a donation or lends a helping hand in a local election.
- Seek endorsements early on from trusted officials and leaders in your community and state. This will boost your name recognition along with voters’ confidence in you as a candidate.
What is the time commitment to be on the school board?
While school boards typically meet only a few times a month, the time commitment to be an effective school board member is considerable. Ahead of meetings, you will need to study materials to make the best possible decisions, ask questions, and do your research on issues you do not fully understand. Beyond board meetings, meetings, work sessions, and district events will require your time and attention.
What is the compensation for a School Board Member?
Most of the time, serving as a school board member is voluntary and unpaid. Some states ban school districts from paying school board members, while others pay their school board members’ salaries. This is different in each state, and it is important to look at your state’s website to determine more information.
6. REQUESTING TO PARTICIPATE IN SELECTING AND APPROVING ACADEMIC STANDARDS WITH THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION
Does the Federal Government Require Academic Standards?
The Federal Law Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) requires each state board of education to develop and implement academic standards and an accountability model that includes indicators of success, addresses subgroups, provides interim measures of progress, and meets long-term goals.
Who Creates the Academic Standards?
Every state board of education submits the ESSA plan to the Department of Education for review and approval. This plan must include the academic standards adopted by the state board of education.
How are Academic Standards different from Curriculum?
State academic standards are the starting point in the curriculum-setting process. They establish the goals and aspirations of what students are expected to master in the classroom. Standards influence testing materials, teacher preparation courses, and teacher professional development training. Curriculum is defined as the courses offered by a school (Merriam-Webster, n.d.). In Pre-K and K-12, the term curriculum is commonly used to refer to all of the academic lessons and content taught within a classroom.
How can Parents be Involved in this Process?
Much like reaching out to the local school board members, grassroots can directly contact the state school board members. You can find contact information for your state board of education members here (on the United States Department of Education website). Ask how you can be involved in the process of developing academic standards. Depending on your state statute, many state boards of education must have a parent serve on the board. A list of how members of the state board of education are selected can be found here (on the Education Commission of the States website).
7. MAKING YOUR VOICE HEARD
What is High-Quality Curriculum?
A A high-quality curriculum is built on high expectations, aligned with robust scholarly standards, is academically rigorous, and is designed to meet all learners’ needs (Steiner, 2017). A high-quality curriculum provides more coherence and connection in the sequencing of learning between grade levels, and high-quality curriculum materials are created to engage students in a deeper level of learning and create a focused direction (National Institute for Excellence in Education).
Research confirms that implementing a “high quality” curriculum leads to improved learning outcomes for students. Curriculum considerations should include multiple research studies with evidence of positive student outcomes over a period of time. Impact on student learning over several years is one of the best determinants of a curriculum’s quality. Curricula like the 1619 Project and CRT have none of the important determinants of research-based impact on student outcomes.
What are The 1619 Project, CRT, Action Civics, and Equity-Based Education?
The 1619 Project: The 1619 Project, and the concept of “reimagining” or “reframing” American history, has become a popular topic since the release of the initiative from The New York Times Magazine in August 2019. The stated goal of this project is “to reframe American history by considering what it would mean to regard 1619 as our Nation’s birth year” (The 1619 Project). The 1619 Project claims that one of the primary reasons the colonists declared their independence from Great Britain was to protect slavery. The 1619 Project purports that slavery was a primary driver of economic growth and infused brutality into American capitalism today. These claims are backed by very few sources and have been widely disputed.
Critical Race Theory (CRT): The intellectual origins of CRT go back to the critical legal studies movement of the 1960s and 1970s that was a byproduct of Marxist critical theory (Britannica, n.d.-a). CRT was officially organized in 1989 and can be explained as follows: “critical race theorists hold that the law and legal institutions in the United States are inherently racist insofar as they function to create and maintain social, economic, and political inequalities between whites and non-whites, especially African Americans (Britannica, n.d.).” CRT is a Marxist-based approach to social and racist unrest. It replaces the traditional Marxist belief in an imbalance of power between workers and capitalists, believing in an imbalance of power between white and non-white citizens. CRT’s rejection of color-blindness and meritocracy threatens to undermine morale in schools and the workplace by making immutable physical characteristics the basis for promotion rather than effort and success.
Action Civics: The goal of action civics is described in Education Week as “not only to teach students how their government works but to harness that knowledge to launch them into collective action on issues they care about (Gewertz, 2019).” This form of teaching is highly controversial, as some view this as legitimizing political protests for class credit.
Equity vs. Equality Focused Education: The divide between equity and equality has been a topic of political debate in the American education system harkening back to the time of Brown v. Board of Education. Curriculum that is equity-based focuses on ensuring everyone has the same outcomes, while equality focuses on ensuring everyone has equal opportunities. Equity demands that treatment must consider race, gender, ethnicity, etc. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. Policies that support equity versus equality can be a threat to the Civil Rights Act because they promote treating subsets of the population (often people of color) differently.
It is important to note that while The 1619 Project, CRT, action civics, and equity in education are frequently discussed, there is a multitude of other theories, policies, and curricula programs that are equally as bad and incorporate the same values. Some examples of these are Learning for Justice Curriculum of the Southern Poverty Law, “We Stories” program of the Educational Equity Consultants, Black Lives Matter curriculum, Teaching for Change curriculum, and the Zinn Education Project. This list is not exhaustive, so it is critical to use the below methods to identify CRT and racially divisive curriculum.
How Do I Identify the Use of This Politically Motivated Curriculum?
It is likely that classroom materials will not outright say “Critical Race Theory” or “The 1619 Project,” so it is vital to scan the materials for keywords or phrases that imply these teachings and result in revisionist history, bigotry, collective guilt, neo-segregation, racial discrimination, and race scapegoating in the classroom.
The Texas Public Policy Foundation has developed a very helpful list of keywords to look for and an explanation of why these are “buzzwords” for politically motivated content. Their list is below:
Equity: This has replaced “equality” for individuals on the Left. Instead of ensuring that every American has an equal opportunity to succeed, equity demands equality of outcomes.
Implicit/unconscious/internalized bias: This is the relentless search to find racism in every aspect of American life. If it is not immediately evident, look harder.
Social Justice/Restorative Justice: This is the belief that society must be torn down and remade in order fully to root out racism.
Systemic racism: According to CRT, racism is the original sin of America, and it persists everywhere to this day. Every institution is designed, they say, “to maintain the dominance of white people in society.”
Microaggressions: These are “subtle insults (verbal, nonverbal and/or visual) directed toward people of color, often automatically or unconsciously.”
Antiracism: This is CRT’s fictitious name, and the practical outworking of its central ideas.
White privilege: According to this doctrine, white people derive immense benefits from their race. According to one theorist (and Wisconsin politician), “America needs to be honest about how race has driven every decision from education to homeownership, and everything in between.”
White fragility: This makes CRT non-falsifiable. Any objection to any tenet of critical race theory is said to be white fragility.
Identity: Everything is about what you are, not who you are.
Ally/Allyship: According to Harvard University, an ally is “Someone who makes the commitment and effort to recognize their privilege (based on gender, class, race, sexual identity, etc.) and work in solidarity with oppressed groups in the struggle for justice.” Critical race theorists demand nothing less of the rest of us.
Social Construct: The idea that race is made-up; it is a fiction used by oppressors to control the oppressed. Oh, and also race is real and immutable. It is the one thing you cannot change about yourself, and it is all that matters (see identity).
Another helpful resource to identify “buzzwords” for divisive concepts can be found here.
How Can I Speak Out Against This?
We know that teachers, principals, and school board members work hard to help children and families. We know that they are not all trying to indoctrinate children through the use of a low-quality curriculum. The concern is more about the well-intentioned but uninformed on how harmful deviating from a high-quality curriculum can be. When speaking out against this, grassroots can:
- Educate school board members, teachers, principals, parents, and other grassroots on the benefits of a high-quality curriculum.
- Provide information on how the public feels about these issues in schools (this data is readily available online, and some are provided below).
- Know your rights and advocate for them.
Below are a handful of data points and talking points to use when speaking out against politically motivated content in your school:
Data Points on High-Quality Curriculum:
- A 2017 report from Johns Hopkins University provided research on the effect of curriculum on student outcomes (Steiner, 2017).
- The authors concluded that a teacher’s or a district’s choice of curriculum significantly affects student learning. The report concluded a positive impact on student achievement using a high-quality curriculum with an increase of as much as 10 percentile points in reading and 23 percentile points in math.
- Studies of the top-performing countries in education worldwide reveal that one of the very few characteristics they share is a high-quality, content-rich curriculum.
- Only 40 percent of teachers reported using a “high-quality and well-aligned curriculum to learning standards” (Voices from the Classroom, 2020).
- A 2017 RAND Corporation survey of 1,100 math and English and language arts teachers found that almost all rely on materials they have developed or selected themselves rather than use the curriculum supplied by their school district (Opfer et al., 2017). The researchers found that 96 percent of teachers surveyed used Google to find lessons and materials, and 75 percent used Pinterest.
- A 2021 report from the Heritage Foundation analyzed the effect of a chief diversity officer (CDO) on student achievement gaps in public schools (Greene, 2021). School districts that employ a CDO claim the position will close student achievement gaps.
- The author gathered nationwide student test-score data and compared public school achievement gaps among schools with and without a CDO. According to the report’s findings, the existence of a CDO in school districts may lead to greater achievement gaps (p. 8). “The achievement gap is half a grade level larger” in districts with CDOs (Greene, p. 8).
Public Opinion of Politically Motivated Curriculum:
- Eighty percent of people surveyed oppose using classrooms to promote political activism to students, including 64 percent who strongly oppose (Parents Defending Education).
- As a national objective, 52 percent prefer “equality” while just 16 percent favor “equity” (Rasmussen).
- Sixty-nine percent of people surveyed opposed schools teaching that America was founded on racism and is structurally racist (Parents Defending Education).
- Regarding offering freedom and equality, 62 percent of voters believe the United States is better than most other nations (Rasmussen).
- Seventy-four percent of people surveyed said they were somewhat or strongly opposed to teaching students that white people are inherently privileged and black and other people of color are inherently oppressed (Parents Defending Education).
Know your rights and advocate for them:
Grassroots have the right to:
- Question and review the curriculum taught in schools by questioning local school boards and school administrators.
- Request access to curriculum plans and instructional materials
- Question and address school officials and school board members at publicly designated meetings with proper notice of the meetings provided.
- Run as a candidate for the local school board.
- Expect that the academic curriculum taught in your district’s schools align with state and federal law.
- Participate in the selection and approval of academic standards for the state.
Talking Points and Questions When Addressing Teachers, Principals, and School Board Members:
- As an American, I stand with the overwhelming majority of people who do not want politically motivated content in school, do not want students to learn that white people are inherently privileged, and prefer equality to equity.
- Widely accepted, evidence-based curricula make a vast difference in educational outcomes. What are you doing to ensure that my children are receiving an evidence-based curriculum? Can you provide evidence that this curriculum has been successful in the past?
- Equality is a principle upon which the country was founded. Our children should be taught about equality, NOT equity.
- Why are we spending time and resources on politically-motivated content when we know our children need a high-quality curriculum to succeed?
- I do not want our students to be taught they are an oppressor or oppressed because of the color of their skin.
- As a taxpayer, I have the right to know what my district’s students are learning, and I would like to be aware of the curriculum, classroom activities, videos, speakers, and books that students will encounter.
- I support using a high-quality curriculum backed by evidence, and I do not support the use of ANY race-centric curriculum or policies.
- I support our students being taught the truth about American history, including the parts of our history I am not proud of. I do NOT support revisionist history or ANY curriculum that teaches systemic racism or that this country was founded on racism.
8. DIRECTING LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS TO USE CIVICS AND HISTORY MATERIALS THAT TEACH NON-BIASED AND NON-POLITICALLY MOTIVATED CONTENT
Understanding the Adoption Process
It is essential to understand the curriculum adoption process in your school district. The United States Constitution does not mention education; public education is a function of the states. This was the true intention of the Founders.
State constitutions include provisions for a system of public schools and usually require a “general, uniform, or efficient” system. State legislative enactment gives local school boards the power and to develop policies, rules, regulations, school finance or budgets, staffing, curriculum, and overall school operations within the district boundaries. Except for the District of Columbia and Hawaii, every state has statutory provisions outlining the local school board’s authority. Hawaii and the District of Columbia have only one single public school district (Education Commission of the States, 2020).
In some states, local school boards, which primarily consist of elected members, have the final approval or denial of a selected curriculum to be used within their schools. Nineteen states have a state-level adoption process for instructional materials. The state-level adoption process means that the State Board of Education creates a pre-approved list of recommended books and materials for implementation. However, the local school board has final approval and can choose materials not on the list. The remaining 31 states allow school districts to select their materials with no input from the state board of education, giving the local districts more flexibility to determine what works best for their specific district.
How to Identify Politically Motivated Civics Education
Carefully reviewing our students’ textbooks, supplemental materials, homework, in-class activities, and digital content can help identify a politically-motivated curriculum and improve our students’ education. Section 7 provides keywords to identify this type of content and data points to speak out against it.
How to Participate in The Curriculum Adoption Process
- Volunteer to participate in committees within the school district, including those of curriculum adoption.
- Attend school board meetings.
- Speak with board members individually and with grassroot groups.
- Contact your school and local school district and sign up to assist in the curriculum process and in school board working sessions.
- Ask questions of teachers, principals, and school board members.
- Do not feel bad about asking questions. It is YOUR community and YOUR tax dollars.
- If the board is not being transparent, you can submit a freedom of information request to obtain desired information.
Alexander, S. Kern, and Alexander, D. (2001). No Title. American Public School Law, 5th Edition
Berry, S. (2021, April 15). California Weighs ‘Equitable Math’: Goal of Getting Correct Answer Racist. Breitbart. https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2021/04/15/california-weighs-equitable-math-goal-obtaining-correct-answer-racist/
Burke, L. M., Butcher, J., Kao, E., & Gonzalez, M. (n.d.). The Culture of American K-12 Education: A National Survey of Parents and School Board Members. Retrieved June 19, 2021, from http://report.heritage.org/sr241
Gewertz, C. (2019, March 20). “Action Civics” Enlists Students in Hands-On Democracy. https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/action-civics-enlists-students-in-hands-on-democracy/2019/03
Greene, P. (2021, October 19). Equity elementary: “Diversity, equity, and inclusion” staff in public schools. Heritage Foundation. https://www.heritage.org/education/report/equity-elementary-diversity-equity-and-inclusion-staff-public-schools
High-Quality Curriculum Implementation The Potential of a High-Quality Curriculum. (n.d.). Retrieved August 22, 2021, from https://www.tn.gov/content/dam/tn/education/data/2019-survey/Lessons_District_Leaders_Infographic.pdf
How are members of the state board of education selected? (2017, November). Education Commission of the States. https://ecs.secure.force.com/mbdata/mbquestNB2?rep=KG1717
It’s Time to Get Involved in Your School Board - Parents Defending Education. (n.d.). Retrieved June 19, 2021, from https://defendinged.org/resources/its-time-to-get-involved-in-your-school-board/
Join Your Local PTA | National PTA. (n.d.). Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://www.pta.org/home/About-National-Parent-Teacher-Association/join/join-community-pta
Meridian Parents group writes Open Letter to School Board… Over 100 Sign | The Fourth Corner | Bellingham | Whatcom. (2021, June 22). The Fourth Corner. https://www.thefourthcorner.com/meridian-citizens-group-organizes-to-communicate-with-school-officials-writes-open-letter/
National Parent Teacher Association | National PTA. (n.d.). Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://www.pta.org/
Opfer, V. Darleen, Julia H. Kaufman, and Lindsey E. Thompson, Implementation of K–12 State Standards for Mathematics and English Language Arts and Literacy: Findings from the American Teacher Panel. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation, 2017. https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR1529-1.html.
Oregon Department of Education adopts Critical Race Theory in Mathematics — Oregonians for Liberty in Education. (2021). Liberty in Education. https://www.libertyineducation.org/blog/oregon-crt-in-mathematic
POLL: Americans Overwhelmingly Reject “Woke” Race and Gender Policies in K-12 Education - Parents Defending Education. (2021, May 10). Parents Defending Education. https://defendinged.org/press-releases/poll-americans-overwhelmingly-reject-woke-race-and-gender-policies-in-k-12-education/
Rasmussen, S. (2021, July 5). 54% Favor Freedom & Equality Candidate; 29% Prefer Social Justice & Equity Candidate. https://scottrasmussen.com/54-favor-freedom-29-prefer-social-justice-equity-candidate/
Rasmussen, S. (2021, July 4). 62% Believe US Offers More Freedom & Equality Than Most Nations, 11% Disagree. https://scottrasmussen.com/62-believe-us-offers-more-freedom-equality-than-most-nations-11-disagree/
Roberts, K. (2021, July 1). How will you know if critical race theory is taught in your child’s school? Texas Public Policy Foundation. https://www.texaspolicy.com/how-will-you-know-if-critical-race-theory-is-taught-in-your-childs-school/?__hstc=204790927.8ea65c43cd17d24af3b6826bdd93b039.1629225167128.1629225167128.1629225167128.1&__hssc=204790927.2.1629225167128&__hsfp=424596134
Robert’s Rules of Order | The Official Website of Robert’s Rules of Order. (n.d.). Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://robertsrules.com/
Rockville Centre High School assignment asserts that police are the sixth leading cause of death for young Black men after cancer - Parents Defending Education. (2021, April 23). Parents Defending Education. https://defendinged.org/incidents/rockville-centre-high-school-assignment-asserts-that-police-are-the-sixth-leading-cause-of-death-for-young-black-men-after-cancer/
Rufo, C. (2021, February 11). Philadelphia 5th Graders Forced to Celebrate “Black Communism." City Journal. https://www.city-journal.org/philadelphia-fifth-graders-forced-to-celebrate-black-communism
Rufo, C. (2021a, January 13). Identity Politics in Cupertino, California Elementary School. City Journal. https://www.city-journal.org/identity-politics-in-cupertino-california-elementary-school
Rufo, C. (2021b, February 23). Buffalo Public Schools’ Critical Race Theory Curriculum | City Journal. City Journal. https://www.city-journal.org/buffalo-public-schools-critical-race-theory-curriculum
Rufo, C. (2021c, March 17). Critical Race Theory in Wake County, NC Schools | City Journal. City Journal. https://www.city-journal.org/critical-race-theory-in-wake-county-nc-schools
Safdar, K., & Eisen, B. (2020, October 6). Labor Department Questions Microsoft and Wells Fargo Over Pledges to Hire More Black Employees - WSJ. Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/articles/microsoft-says-u-s-government-questions-its-pledge-to-hire-more-black-employees-11602020480
School board elections, 2020 - Ballotpedia. (n.d.). Ballotpedia. Retrieved August 22, 2021, from https://ballotpedia.org/School_board_elections,_2020
Southeastern Legal Foundation (June 29, 2021). Deemar v. Evanston/Skokie School District 65. https://www.slfliberty.org/case/deemar-v-evanston-skokie-school-district-65/
State Contacts and Information. (n.d.). United States Department of Education. Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://www2.ed.gov/about/contacts/state/index.html
State Freedom of Information Laws – National Freedom of Information Coalition. (n.d.). National Freedom Of Information Coalition. Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://www.nfoic.org/state-freedom-of-information-laws/
State sunshine laws - Ballotpedia. (n.d.). Ballotpedia. Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://ballotpedia.org/State_sunshine_laws
Steiner, D. (2017). Curriculum Research: What We Know and Where We Need to Go.
The 1619 Project - The New York Times. (2019, August). The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/08/14/magazine/1619-america-slavery.html
Zorc, L. (n.d.). Vocabulary for Understanding 21st Century Wokeness in-Education. Freedom Works. Retrieved August 19, 2021, from https://parentsknowbest.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Vocabulary-for-Understanding-21st-Century-Wokeness-in-Education-3.pdf
May 31, 2023
ISSUE BRIEF: How the Administrative State is Being Used to Criminalize Lawful Gun Owners
Although recent victories for the Second Amendment in the United States Supreme Court, such as New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022), may give many Americans the…
May 31, 2023
AFPI Launches Messaging and Data Lab
May 31, 2023
AFPI Debt Ceiling Deal Policy Takeaways
In February 2023, AFPI published a debt ceiling primer that contained recommendations to address the country’s unsustainable fiscal path and implement policies that put the American…